THRU BLACK & WHITE EYES – The Blame Game – 22/Jun/14

by • June 22, 2014 • TBAWEComments (8)1192

Why does Alan Pardew bother to pretend anymore? Why does he bother to pretend he is SissokoFRAreally a person whose wants, needs or hopes, matter at at Newcastle United?  I ask because last week when he made two claims about what happened last season and what was currently going on in preparation for next season, I found my previous sense that Pardew’s management of our club is merely futile start turn to contempt for the “manager” at Newcastle United.

According to Pardew an explanation for last season’s post-January collapse was caused by the prospect of the World Cup and the impact that had upon many of our players. What is Pardew suggesting here? Is he suggesting our players pulled out of games, pretended to be injured or failed to give100% in games because they wished to preserve themselves for the World Cup? He has already denied that was the case with Loic Remy despite our former on-loan striker claiming the manager connived with him to keep him out of the last fixture of the season to preserve him for French international duty.

Is Pardew claiming that Krul, Debuchy, Tiote, Sissoko, Ameobi and Remy for example deliberately did not commit to Newcastle United post-Christmas? How does he therefore explain the loss of form, and favour for Hatem Ben Arfa, Sylvain Marveaux, Yoan Gouffran, Steven Taylor, Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa and Davide Santon none of whom are anywhere near Brazil currently? How does he explain the poor contributions of Vurnon Anita and the lamentable performances of Luuk De Jong with reference to the World Cup?

Does this explain our inability to take a corner, free-kick, play without any width, creativity, score goals, ever come back from going a goal behind and did the impending World Cup persuade us that our best form of attack was to larrup the ball up the field without any sense of creativity at all?

The Premier League has become a polyglot of nationalities plying their trades at its clubs. Did the World Cup distract those I’ve seen in the colours of many international sides from Manchester City, Manchester United, Liverpool, Chelsea, Arsenal, Everton, West Brom, Swansea, Sunderland, Fulham and probably every other club in the Premier League?

Or is this just the latest nonsense from a manager who looks ever more the charlatan by the day?

To be fair to Pardew, he did touch upon the failure of the club to replace Cabaye but where was the fuller explanation for the blunders, cramping lack of ambition, idiotic decision-making and woeful investment for two successive transfer windows? Joe Kinnear anyone?

Where is the reference to the collective failure of everyone at Newcastle United to bring through a single player from the Development Squad into the first team for the entire period of Ashley’s tenure at Newcastle United? Where is the reference to the club’s grotesque incompetence in failing to secure Cat.1 status for the Academy two years ago at the same time as most other clubs of similar and lesser stature?

Where is the reference to his own shortcomings? His inability to motivate, coach, prepare and improve players as individuals? Where is the reference to his own inability to develop an identifiable playing style amongst a collection of international footballers? Who can say what style an Alan Pardew plays in?

Blaming the World Cup in 2014 is an echo of the blame he lumped onto the Europa League in 2013.

In the words of the taunt we heard last season: “Alan Pardew, it’s never your fault”.

Not that it ended there.

Pardew gave us a real laugh out loud moment with the claim United and he was doing everything it could to strengthen the squad for next season. Jesus Christ, how dumb does this man take us for? Charnley is the latest hapless jerk sent by Ashley to a gun-fight with a pea-shooter and all of the indications are he is doing the football equivalent of transfer tyre-kicking with bids falling way short of value and wages wholly out of range of what players can get elsewhere. The press is reporting acid commentary of United’s transfer modus operandi from club presidents, agents, players et al.

Does anyone need any further evidence of the abysmal matter in which our club is being run by Mike Ashley?

Unless something radical changes and changes quickly, this next season is going to be a disaster.


I have to say last week, I had something of an epiphany. I’ve never been what you could ENGfansdescribe as an England fan. I’m not hostile to the national team, more indifferent to the whole Flags of St George on foreign cars hullabaloo and alienated by the small town “No Surrender” dullards who have filled the stands at games down the years. Similarly, I’m not fond of its London-centred focus and I had started to take more interest when games came to our city and others across the North whilst that massive white elephant in the London Borough of Brent was being constructed as a vanity project for the FA.

No, last week, somewhat obviously I accept, I started to understand just how much the national team matters, its value and what it says about how our game in this country is run. And that includes Newcastle United. Now, don’t expect me to start turning out dressed in the height of summer in a Crusaders costume but the England team really does matter. There will be some of my acquaintance who will gasp at my having written that sentence whilst others will comment wryly, “he’s fucking quick isn’t he?”

It is a statement of the bleeding obvious that there aren’t enough English players for an England manager to choose from and there aren’t many English managers for the FA to select a successor to Hodgson from either. Pulis, Allardyce, Pardew (ha-ha), Bruce? I know, I know.

Let’s go back to the early 90s and the formation of the Premier League. One of the driving forces for the formation of the Premier League was that it would support the England team. Then, one of the primary explanations for the then failures of the national team was that we played too many games in England and that the top division should be reduced. That never happened and now the top players of every major league play more games than ever before due to the Champions League.

However, if anything explains the dearth of English talent emerging across the game it is the Premier League’s clubs and their obsession with money. Every club is after the quick fix, every club is looking in the short term.

That is why Newcastle United shops (when it shops at all) for cheaper foreign imports and provides more opportunities for young French players to develop in the Premier League than it does from its own door-step, the traditional hot-bed of football that is the North East of England.

I am not blaming England’s failures upon Mike Ashley’s running of Newcastle United but he and others are playing their role in the national team’s decline.

Something deeper than Ashley’s Frenchies at United is going on.

At Italia 90, Sacriston’s Bobby Robson took an England with Dunston’s Gascoigne, Pelaw’s Waddle, Longbenton’s Beardsley, Chester-le-Street’s Robson and Berwick’s Steven to the semi-final of the World Cup. Bobby’s team was a penalty shoot out from getting to the final. It is inconceivable the national team will get that far again.

At Brazil 2014, Jordan Henderson became the first ever born and bred Mackem ever to play at a World Cup. Fenham’s Shola Ameobi made a cameo appearance for Nigeria. Hexham’s Fraser Forster never got off the bench. That was the North East’s sole contribution to the World Cup. Hotbed? Hmm. Not any more.

Something is going badly wrong. Admittedly, Andy Carroll’s career seems to be going backwards after promising so much at United and when I see Ricki Lambert playing for England and the Teams’ finest posing with nubile young women on holiday in Vegas, you wonder if the player I still yearn to see in a B&W shirt will ever fulfil his potential. As if he’s bothered.

Even when United was by and large shit during the 70s and 80s, many of us took a vicarious pride in seeing lads from the North East at the top clubs and it convinced us of the latent potential of our club. Armstrong, Bell, Kennedy (R). Kennedy (A), Richardson, Bruce and many more showed the enthusiasm there was for the game – basically it was in the North East’s DNA.

I was an absolutely shit footballer but even somehow, miraculously on occasion found myself on the same pitch as David Hodgson (Boro, Liverpool, Sunderland, England), Chris Waddle (Newcastle United, Tottenham, Marseille, Sheff. Wed, England), Wes Saunders (Newcastle United) and Neil Aspin (Leeds United). I am sure others reading this of a similar vintage have similar stories to tell (my brother played against Paul Gascoigne several times and he was only marginally less shit than me). You will also hear the oft-repeated sentiment that those lads that went on to make it as professionals (and there were plenty more local lads who played throughout the Football League) they weren’t the best of what was available. Basically, there were plenty to choose from.

I am utterly convinced the explanation for the dearth in English talent can’t be summed up with a quick and easy sentence expressed by a fanzine knacker or anyone else. What I do believe however is that Michel Platini’s caustic riposte to the problems of developing English players: “too much money” gets to the hub of it.

If a club like United can go and get unremarkable players like Obertan, Gouffrann, Haidara and others rather than recruit from the Football League or the Development Squad because they represent better value or are of better quality then this means native-born players will not graduate to the next level. There is no escalator of success.

Then you have to ask why the native born players available in the lower divisions aren’t available in sufficient numbers to rise through the ranks. Why do so many players who leave the Academies of PL and Championship clubs simply disappear out of football? Wouldn’t it have been better for those players to have been playing proper football for a league club at whatever level and progressing rather than fannying on in the world of Development Squads around the country?

You also have to wonder about the standard of coaching available to young players. It is a well-known fact that there is a paucity of suitably qualified and licensed coaches in the UK when compared to Spain, Italy, France and Germany. How can France continually provide players for Newcastle United and the Premier League who are better than those from around the North East and available in the Football League? Many of those players come from under-privileged backgrounds but on the whole are more technically proficient than our own?

English football is awash with money but so little of it finds its way to the grassroots of the game but rather the pockets of mercenary players (from home and abroad), people like Ashley, charlatan managers like Pardew and of course the reviled agents.

Why can the UK compete so convincingly internationally with athletics, cricket, rugby but not football?

There may be something culturally going adrift with football but the sporting prowess of the country remains so obviously intact when you look at other areas.

One thing is certain and that is the likes of Mike Ashley and others at major PL clubs aren’t going to behave in ways that are supportive to the national team when alternative strategies might actually deprive them of money they and their clubs expect as their right.


Everyone at true faith wishes Bob Moncur all the very best as he faces treatment for Cancer. We may not think much of Bob’s defence of Mike Ashley but I’m sure all fans, like us send Bob Moncur, his friends and family all the very best wishes at this time.


Many thanks to all of you have signed up for the true faith DIGITAL subscription. tf112_mirandinha_ipadWe have received some brilliant feedback about the SUMMER SPECIAL, the first we have knocked out entirely in DIGITAL format and we are really pleased at the numbers taking out subscriptions.

We’ll soon be letting everyone know about the publication schedule for next season but we are also keen to recruit more writers to our existing ranks of scribblers. The DIGITAL format allows us to add more content and that gives more opportunities to more supporters to express their opinions about their club and football in general.

If you would like to know more about writing for true faith, just drop us a line on

To take out a DIGITAL subscription simply click here. We offer an annual subscription for £17.99 and a quarterly subscription for £5.99.

Once you have subscribed, you will get instant access to the current SUMMER SPECIAL issue as well as a back catalogue of 30 previous issues. Your subscription will also cover every issue we publish next season and that will be a minimum of eight.

Have a great week.

Keep On, Keepin’ On … TF_INITIALS_LOGO

Related Posts

8 Responses to THRU BLACK & WHITE EYES – The Blame Game – 22/Jun/14

  1. SteveP says:

    The best Frenxh talent is spotted early, fron age 12, regardless of where in France they come from, they go to Clairfontaine. Do their schoololing there and get coached.
    Over here, the academy system tries to make too many players with a means to an end of making tbe clubs money (which you said), be that through prize money for winning things or from them being sold later on down the line (a reason why NUFC couldn’t get cat 1?, cos they’re not interested in winning stuff???)
    The premier league is what it is because of the foreigners, without them, it’d be like the Belgian league only slightly more interesting (to us possibly). 30 something percent of all the players picked to play in the 2013/14 season were English (or British depending on who’s stats you use), that’s disgraceful for a top league in europe. Where are all the english players playing abroad and can you name any of them??
    Alan Pardew should really just shut his mouth and extend the press ban to everybody, the longer his reign goes on, the more contradictions and bullshit he comes out with, just making himself look even more a caricature of the puppet we know him to be.

  2. Rob says:

    As mentioned in this, the “I Wish I was a Geordie” lads had it right on their podcast- one of the major indictments against Pardew is that he’s been here for quite a while, and yet has made absolutely no imprint upon the team in terms of style of play. There’s an argument though a slim one I think) that he can’t be asked to implement a style of play when he has his best players sold- but quite frankly I have no idea on a game by game basis what his tactical philosophy is (I know talking tactics is very unsexy but it’s his major problem).
    Did so well playing 4-3-3 towards the end of ’11/12, and then straight back to 4-4-2 the first game of the following season, despite the fact that prior to adopting the 4-3-3, Ba and Cisse had looked poor as a front pair. The mantra that seems to have (thankfully) died a death, that Pardew likes to play a passing game. When? Where? How? The last two seasons we’ve done so only sporadically.
    We don’t have an identity on the pitch in any way. We just take goals as they come to us, there is no regular strategy through which we try to score. Last season that was thankfully covered up by Remy and Cabaye, I’m not sure we’ll do it next season without significant signings.

  3. Matt Flynn says:

    Pardew may have touched on the impact selling Cabaye had on the second half of last season but still insists that we “lost” him. As if his absence from the NUFC first team post January was an accident. Akin to losing your car keys or misplacing the TV remote. Simply doesn’t have the balls to tell it as it is.

    The bottom line with England is that the players aren’t very good. Either just plain average (Henderson) or nowhere near as good as their hype (Rooney). Who is to blame for this dearth of English talent? Just about everybody on the PL gravy train.

    Be interesting to see it Gerrard does the right thing and retires. He’s been blocking the next generation for years, as have a few others.

  4. Nocapital Expenditure says:

    Pulis is a taff isn’t he?

  5. Greeny's guitar says:

    Michael, an excellent article but why haven’t you mentioned the significant part played by those odius bastards at Sky

  6. Joe says:

    You can – and usually do – win championships with a squad of cherry-picked stars that can be rotated according to form. It doesn’t work at international tournaments though, for obvious reasons. Until England can differentiate between what works in the Premier League for a set of players that play together every day to train for a 40-odd game season, and what works for a month outside the player’s comfort zone, then they will continue to fail.
    Simply(?!) pick the most in-form English players in their position over the two months previous to international tournaments, regardless of whether that means Stoke’s centre-half is lumping balls up to Leicester’s on-fire centrre-forward. If you can stick a fancy dan in midfield to provide a bit of scenery, then all the better. But lets not put assumptions on the team because they cost £X ammount, or they were part of a squad that finished runners-up in the league.

  7. Danny says:

    I remember the time when just about every first division team in England had two or three gifted Scots players and maybe one or two Irish as well. A look through NUFC history will show the top players we have had over the years from Scotland.

    Now there are virtually no really decent Scottish players and we get cheap foreign imports, but who cares as long as the premier league gravy train keeps rolling.. In a few years time England will be at the level that Scotland is at now.

    The premier league is all about greed and money corrupts, England in the world cup? best forget that dream we are not likely to be competitive at that level again unless their is a real sea change.

  8. JACKSON YATES says:

    In a numbers of ways Newcastle United is becoming a textbook Premier League club. Stay on the gravy train at all costs. Forget about winning anything – it’s not worth the bother. Dispense with any sense of locality – Generic FC. Buy into the ‘mini-leagues’ mentality to create an illusion of success. Absolve yourself from any wider responsibilities in football – it’s someone else’s problem.