REPORT & PODCAST: Man City 3 Newcastle United 1, Etihad Stadium, 20/Jan/18, KO: 5:30pm, Premier League, Att: 54,452

by • January 21, 2018 • Match reportsComments (8)1161





There is a widely shared feeling that it would be wonderful for Newcastle United to enjoy the same good fortune as Man City and be taken over by some money-no-object operation and for the club to be catapulted into the rarefied atmosphere the recently minted Mancunians now enjoy. Let’s be honest, who wouldn’t love the sight of some of the world’s greatest players turning out in our colours and sending SJP into raptures with some of the best football ever played on these shores.  Aguero, Silva, De Bruyne and Sane would get into any team in the world. They are one of the few teams playing nowadays I’ll bother to switch the telly onto watch. They play marvellous football.

There is a flip-side however. And that is Man City are no longer Man City. The club that once played at Maine Road, was avowedly a working class Mancunian institution is no more. It is dead. In its place is a growing corporate behemoth, an expression of economic power that no club on the planet can compete with. Where once trips to Maine Road were negotiated with your eyes and ears wide-open in the in the unforgiving streets of Mossside, now there is a replacement stadia and set-up, that whilst dripping of money, has all of the excitement and edge of a trip to an out of town retail park. Man City fans once sneered at the day-tripper experience of their cross town rivals but the truth is they are a tribute act to their red neighbours, simply minus the romance and heritage of the tourist attraction at Trafford Park.

I don’t think I’ve experienced a more controlled environment than the one at the Etihad. The layered security, sniffer dogs and body-searches is all completely over the top outside but the pitch-side interviews with Paul Power (ask your Dad) talking about how he’d loved to have played in this Man City team (fat chance, Paul) and how his team needed another goal, blasting into your eyes and ears was pure TV experience and made me wondered why I’d paid for the real thing when the telly-version is the one being provided right in front of us.

Manchester City Thanks Sheik Mansour!

That’s a flag hung from the stand. I’ve seen it before. I almost chuck every time I see it. Then there’s the virtual flags meant to be fluttering over the stands. Do me a favour!

Where Were You When You Were Shit?

Obviously, this rankles with the home crowd because that support is proud of the way some of it’s support stuck by Man City in less financially doped days at Maine Road, when they were a proper club. I laughed when they sung it back to the away end, blissfully ignorant it seems, of the Championship team we are following in the Premier League.

If there is one thing our support utterly owns and it’s the moral high ground.

Anyway. The football. We defied the odds and as ever Rafa’s team, up against it, weren’t found wanting for organisation, effort and courage. But we simply lack quality to take a game to a side of Man City’s stellar ability for any length of time.

Sterling had the ball in the back of the net before Aguero scored yet another against us. I’ve not seen any highlights of the game since I left the match but an incoming text advised me we’d had a let-off and the goal should have stood.

I’d hoped we’d have gotten to half-time NILs apiece but that wasn’t to be. One thing I’d say about Rafa’s team and that is their heads never drop. I’ve been here to see United torn apart under Souness, Pardew and McClaren and frankly those sides stopped playing, chucked it in and various players hid, disgracing the shirt. Rafa’s lads, short of quality that they are definitely are, never do that and that’s why I’ll never get angry with them. That fury is reserved for a fat twat in Berkshire who should take the advice of the away end and get out of our club.

Lascelles is emerging as an excellent leader of the club. I’ve no desire for him to go to Russia in the words of the song because if he progresses to a certain level, he’ll be sold. I thought Dummett was spot on, committed and clever. He’s a good, solid professional that lad and it is utterly shameful how he has been treated by the yahoos in our support.

Fair play to Diame who put in a good shift and it appears more supporters are coming to the view Jacob Murphy is improving and is an asset to United. For me, Darlow looked assured, his goalkeeping was competent and eye-catching on a couple of occasions.

I can’t say what I think of their penalty. I thought it was a pen, I thought I saw hands on the lad’s back but those who’ve seen the telly replays from a hundred different angles will have a different view.

I was pleasantly surprised by our goal. It seemed to come out of the blue (pun intended) but credit to Murphy who kept his composure and at 2-1, the away end found hope much to the chagrin of the weirdos in the home end who took to scrapping with each other and embarrassing themselves with gloating gestures towards us. Man U fans do that thing much better lads and there aren’t quite so many 40-year old virgins amongst them.

The third killed the game but you know, like the game at SJP, our two-bob, raggy-arsed bunch of triers was in the game right to the finish and didn’t allow themselves to be torn apart.

They did themselves and their manager justice but Newcastle United should be about a lot more than that. Under Ashley it never will be and if the manager leaves and the takeover fails, nights like this, when we were even competing against one of the world’s best, with two hands toed behind our back will seem like the good old days.


MICHAEL MARTIN – Follow Michael on @tfMichael1892  


You can still access the true faith matchday Newsletter, THE SPECIAL just click here  

true faith is Newcastle United’s longest running and most widely read fanzine. It is one of the most prominent and respected fanzine titles in the UK. It is definitely one of the hardest working. This is issue 136 of the fanzine. It is FREE to download now and you can read it offline and on any device you like. For best results we recommend a tablet or i-pad. true faith is written by supporters for supporters. It is for people who like to read about Newcastle United and football in general.  We do something a bit different. This is avowedly a partisan Geordie publication but also internationalist. You won’t get pop-ups, click-bait, recycled second hand cut and paste news and we won’t lazily reheat nonsense about SKY pundits. We’ll leave that to others. We respect you all too much to go down that road. This is good, solid, old fashioned fanzine writing for the modern supporter in a digital, modern format. Our reading figures for the fanzine are truly astonishing. Each issue, our readership grows and so our audience gets ever bigger. We must be doing something right.

Just click on the image as below and its all yours.

Related Posts

8 Responses to REPORT & PODCAST: Man City 3 Newcastle United 1, Etihad Stadium, 20/Jan/18, KO: 5:30pm, Premier League, Att: 54,452

  1. Bob says:

    A bit more quality and composure in the second half when we ventured forward and we might, just might, have got something. Poor final ball on a couple of occasions when it looked easier to find the player. Sterling was offside, albeit not much but still offside and, as rafa said the pen was soft – wish we could get at least one of those!

  2. Castle Farm Mag says:

    I enjoyed an enthralling match, even though in reality we were no ‘match’ for them at all. Foe me, the work-rate and effort still induced pride. Agree totally with the “Manchester City Thanks Sheik Mansour” banner – it’s teeth-itchingly naff – and can only have been dreamed up by an insider lick-spittle. Yes, a tidy ground but so anodyne. Got back into the centre quickly on the fast tram system. Splitting the away fans across the tiers dilutes the atmosphere we could generate somewhat – good idea for them though, I suppose.

  3. SREXR says:

    Offside requires a part of the body that can legally score to be ‘in front of the line’ – in this case it was Sterlings hand/arm – the rest of him was level or behind the last defender. fwiw.

    • SREXR says:

      And I thought Newcastle did well. Rafa’s tactics are decent and playing a very defensive game for much of the match and then pushing up late in the game makes a lot of sense. City are way off their best and some players like de Bruyne need to be rested – though its probably too late to make a difference in what is achieved this season. There’s lots of money to be thrown at ‘consumer experience’ events and it makes sense that Newcastle would attract someone with deep pockets to join the bigger clubs. And by bigger I’m referring to the resources available.

  4. Del says:

    Top effort but each was playing within himself to the betterment of the team plan, saving it for the day when we rock up against equal fodder. Rafa is working beneath his stature but still his reputation can only be enhanced by his honourable and respectful demeanour. The same cannot be said for the likes of Pep, who, with the riches at his disposal should have nothing but good things to say about his opponents – unless they are resorting to Sham or Pulis style brutal tactics – instead he acts like a spoilt Manc Utd brat with childish comments that Mouninho or Whinger would be proud of.
    Once we wave tara to the large lad in Herts we can start to enjoy what follows but hope that the ‘better’ players have the same heart that these lads have.

  5. R says:

    And NUFC is no longer NUFC, the crowd generates half the noise it did 30 years ago even though there are now double the fans and we have a roof over the whole ground to keep the noise in. We have a billionaire owner from Slough who has plastered his firms hideous logos all over the ground AND we are shit into the bargain. I’d love to see someone do a poll at the gate on where our fans are from, bet there ain’t many from Scotchie, Blakelaw, and Elswick anymore. NUFC a working class club?, nah.

  6. Tony Higgins says:

    Great Match report that. Man City away about 5 years ago was the time that I finally threw the towel in. I looked around and thought if this is success you can keep it…. awful place.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *